The prospect of Itamar Ben-Gvir, the current Minister of National Security, being appointed as Israel's Defense Minister has become a significant point of contention within Israeli political circles. Ben-Gvir, known for his hardline nationalist positions, has frequently advocated for more aggressive military and security policies regarding the West Bank and Gaza.

Haaretz, in an editorial piece, characterizes the potential appointment as a "nightmare scenario" for the country. The outlet argues that placing Ben-Gvir in charge of the defense establishment would lead to severe diplomatic isolation, exacerbate tensions with the Palestinian population, and potentially undermine the professional independence of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). The editorial suggests that his past rhetoric and legal history make him fundamentally unsuited for a role that requires balancing complex regional security interests with international law and diplomatic stability.

Conversely, supporters of Ben-Gvir within the coalition argue that the current defense establishment has been too restrained. They contend that a change in leadership at the Ministry of Defense is required to implement a more assertive strategy against security threats. Proponents suggest that Ben-Gvir’s focus on deterrence aligns with the mandate given to the current government by its voters. While the debate remains largely speculative, it highlights a deep ideological divide regarding the future direction of Israel's security apparatus and its relationship with the international community.