Nine months following the official reopening of Melbourne’s City Square, the area is reportedly struggling to attract significant numbers of visitors. Observations from the site suggest that the square remains largely vacant, with some observers noting that the presence of seagulls currently outweighs the number of people using the space.

The project, which was intended to revitalize a central urban hub, has faced criticism regarding its current utility and vibrancy. While the infrastructure is complete, the lack of consistent public engagement has led to descriptions of the square as a "ghost town." There is currently no consensus on why the space has failed to draw crowds, though the contrast between the initial expectations for the site and the current reality is a point of concern for local observers. The situation highlights a disconnect between the city's urban planning goals and the actual usage patterns of residents and tourists in the post-reopening phase.