Gloria Steinem remains a defining figure of second-wave feminism, a movement that has frequently faced criticism for being perceived as exclusionary or overly aggressive. Supporters and commentators often highlight Steinem’s role in reshaping the public perception of feminism during the mid-to-late 20th century.

While some historical critiques characterize second-wave feminism as dour or hostile toward men, Steinem is frequently cited as an alternative to this narrative. Proponents of her work describe her as a figure who brought wit, warmth, and glamour to the movement, effectively challenging the notion that feminist activism had to be joyless or strictly academic. By emphasizing the concept of 'sisterhood,' Steinem sought to build a coalition that was inclusive and focused on shared liberation.

There is ongoing discussion regarding the effectiveness of these early feminist strategies. While some analysts view Steinem’s approach as a necessary bridge that made feminist ideals accessible to a broader public, others argue that the focus on individual personality and glamour may have overshadowed deeper systemic critiques. Despite these differing interpretations of her impact, there is a consensus that Steinem’s personal brand was instrumental in defining the public face of the women's liberation movement for decades.